2019 Playoffs

Already know who you’re rooting for in the MLB playoffs this year? Or totally lost to the One True Faith? You might as well skip this post. Come back Wednesday–I may have another post this week–or Friday for the cats. The rest of you, gather around.

Sure, you can watch the playoffs without rooting for anyone. But where’s the fun in that? This post aims to help you choose a rooting interest, whether you want to pick a single team to follow throughout the month or pick a new team in each series.

Again, this isn’t about picking a winner. I’ve made those predictions, and I won’t revisit them until November. (As a reminder–Spoilers, Darling!–I picked the Dodgers to win it all. There’s still time to call Vegas.)

If you’re new to this blog, you may be surprised to hear there are rules for choosing a rooting interest. But why should something so important be left to whim and chance?

Rules for Rooting, 2019 edition

  1. Unless it’s the team you follow during the regular season, you must not root for any team that has been promoted as “America’s Team” or otherwise held up by its owners and/or the media as the ultimate expression of the sport. If you do root for one of these teams, this is a great time to reconsider your life choices.
  2. You should not root for a team from your own team’s division.
  3. That said, you should root for somebody from your own league. Crossing the league boundary without a really good excuse is in bad taste.
  4. Possession of team merchandise with sentimental value OR a history of following a favorite player from team to team trumps Rules Two and Three. It does not override Rule One. Nothing overrides Rule One.
  5. Teams with a record of recent futility or legitimate “misfit” credentials get bonus points in the decision process. A record of futility means multiple losing seasons or a lengthy stretch without a playoff appearance and/or title. What constitutes legitimate misfittery is up to you. Be honest with yourself.
  6. All other rules notwithstanding, you are always free to root for the Indians, holders of a seventy season World Series drought.

That said, rooting for the Indians this year would be an exercise in Zen Futility, since they’re not in the playoffs. But I digress.

Since I’m writing as much as possible of this post ahead of time, we’ll start with the National League, where the teams were set by the middle of last week.

The National League playoff teams are Atlanta, Washington, St. Louis, Milwaukee, and Los Angeles.

As always, Rule One applies to the Braves, thanks to Ted Turner. It also applies to the Nationals (for obvious reasons) and the Dodgers.

We’ll award a futility point to the Brewers, whose fans have now been waiting for a World Series title for half a century.

Dodgers, Nationals, and Braves followers can take the next couple of days for reflection. Fans of the other NL East and West teams have an obvious pick in the Brewers. And, much as I hate to encourage violation of Rule Two, it’s a lesser offense than breaking Rule One. So those of you who usually cheer for the Cubs, Reds, or Pirates should also be rooting for Milwaukee.

Now, on to the American League, where the playoff teams weren’t settled until Friday. The Junior Circuit has given us New York, Minnesota, Houston, Oakland, and Tampa Bay.

Fortunately for my sanity, there’s only one AL playoff team subject to Rule One–the Yankees, of course.

We’ll give the Athletics and Twins a futility point each, since their World Series droughts are at twenty-nine and twenty-seven years, respectively. (Last year, I gave the As a misfit point, primarily because of Khris Davis’ four-year streak of hitting exactly .247. That string ended this year–he finished at .220–so no misfit point for the As.)

Yankees boosters, go meditate on your media-enabled sins.

Non-playoff affiliated fans, your guidance looks like this: If you’re normally in the AL East or Central, you should looking west to cheer for the Athletics. If you’re from the West Division, the Twins are your crew. Simple, huh?

And, as always, if you don’t normally follow baseball–whether because you’ve lost the True Faith or never been properly entered in the rolls of the Faithful–you can exercise your free will. You can choose your team based on geography, following the guidelines above. Or take the easy way out and root for the As. Or exercise your masochistic side and root for the Indians.

And to reiterate: Even though I’ve predicted the Dodgers to win the Series, you can not root for them unless they were your team through the regular season. Even if you’ve got money down. Rule One is absolute.

8 thoughts on “2019 Playoffs

  1. I hope I will be forgiven if I do cross over, and become an A’s fan, since they have made it into the playoffs, and the Giants…I don’t want to talk about it.
    By some standards, I should have been an A’s fan, all along, since I live in Oakland. I confess, I already have the hat, ready to wear- but Kelly green clashes horribly with the rest of my wardrobe.
    Spoken like a true, effete, Giants fan, right?


    • I figure as long as you don’t wear the As cap with the Giants jersey, you’re (green and) golden.

      And, yeah, we all know only usthose West Bay folks worry about color coordination. Says the guy wearing the blue Pilots cap with the orange socks (one for the Giants and one for the Orioles).


  2. I’m breaking some of your rules … but as an Orioles fan, it would be kind of you to cut me some slack. I’ve had a tough summer. I’m hanging with rule #4, which does break rule #1 in places — two of my all-time favorite Orioles are in the post-season … Jonathan Schoop (Twins), Nick Markakis (Braves) … and I never ever ever root against a former University of Virginia player and there are a few, but especially Sean Doolittle (Nats), Chris Taylor (Dodgers).

    And, from there I follow the one most important rule for Baltimore fans: ABTY, Anyone But The Yankees.

    I’m just happy to have a few weeks of baseball games that won’t end with the reminder, “Be patient. Rebuilds take time.”


    • Rule breaking is between you and your conscience. Ain’t no Baseball Fan Police, no matter what you might read on the Internet.

      Lest we forget, Chris Taylor is also a former Mariner. Still not rooting for the Dodgers, though.

      And yes, ABTY. I wonder how much it would cost to have a skywriter inscribe it over Yankee stadium just before game time on Friday.


  3. Pingback: 2020 Playoffs | Koi Scribblings

  4. Pingback: A Heartfelt Thank You | Koi Scribblings

  5. Pingback: It’s That Time of Year Again | Koi Scribblings

  6. Pingback: Oh, Is It October Already? | Koi Scribblings

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.